Still Not a Robot

Still Not a Robot

Friday Footnote: How to say "No" in Japanese

Alia Luria's avatar
Alia Luria
Aug 25, 2023
βˆ™ Paid

The finger X, hand X, or forearm X (you may have noticed πŸ™…πŸ»β€β™€οΈ among your emojis and wondered about it) is a common sign employed by Japanese people to inform someone else that they either cannot do something they are about to do or be somewhere they are about to go. I was once given a forearm X by a security guard when I attempted to walk through an entrance that was closed off, and sometimes a finger X or hand X, usually held lower on the body, if something I wanted wasn’t available in a store or not an option at a restaurant. Usually, it would appear when asking for an eigo no menu (English menu). The gesture will often be used in lieu of saying β€œNo.” Sometimes it will accompany the β€œNo”, but Japanese people generally, really, absolutely hate to say iie, or β€œno”. Maybe that’s because its literal translation of iie is β€œThat’s incorrect.” And I can see how it might be rude to tell someone they are being incorrect. In his book Dave Barry Does Japan, the American humor writer Dave Ba…

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Alia Luria.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
Β© 2026 Alia Luria Β· Privacy βˆ™ Terms βˆ™ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture